Content quality, helpful content and E-E-A-T
Crawl and rendered views agree on every verdict, so the findings are content gaps, not delivery problems. There is no authorship signal (8.4) and no citation apparatus (8.5) on any priority page, and 4 pages lack sameAs links (8.7). Judgement calls with no site-side observable are held rather than forced into a verdict.
Deferred. This needs the keyword-pattern evidence from cluster 9, and judging intent on copy that is about to be rewritten would date the verdict. It will be decided together with 9.8, its near-duplicate, on the same evidence.
Across all 300 pairs of priority pages, the highest body-text overlap is 0.17 (Jaccard over 8-token shingles), and most pairs sit at 0.02 to 0.04. Nothing is template-generated, and word counts vary widely, so nothing was written to a target length. The client confirmed that no automation was used and that every entry is reviewed before publication.
States a property of Google's E-E-A-T framework, not a requirement a site can meet or fail.
None of the 25 priority pages carries an authorship signal: no rel=author, byline, author meta tag or page-level JSON-LD author. The rule is structural rather than a text sweep, because body prose such as 'written by' about a subject would have produced a false Pass. Whether to use named or institutional bylines is an editorial decision, so this is a recommendation, not a defect report.
No citation apparatus on any of the 25 pages in either view: no references or sources section, no outbound links to DOIs or catalogues, no JSON-LD citation property, no footnote markers. This is the heaviest finding in the cluster, because the pages carry long factual text with nothing a reader can verify against.
No disclosure text or methodology link on any of the 25 pages. No automation was used, so no AI disclosure is owed. The claim's first clause is not conditional, though: it asks a site to explain how content was created, and this site does not. One methodology page would serve 8.4, 8.5 and 8.6 at once.
21 of 25 pages carry both Wikidata and Wikipedia in the subject's sameAs. Four carry no sameAs at all, though all four subjects have those records, so this is unpopulated data rather than an entity with nothing to point at. The site's own social profiles are counted separately, because self-published profiles don't disambiguate an entity.
The site's subject matter does not bear on health, finances, safety or societal welfare, so it is non-YMYL. A lower bar is still a bar, so this does not soften 8.4 or 8.5.
Want this run on your site?
We test your site against the same claims, record a verdict and the evidence for each one, and tell you what to fix first.
Start a conversation